What are your thoughts? Do you think schools should be nut free? Remember that there are children, like my Emmy, who cannot even tough peanut butter without having a reaction. What is the policy at your school? I'd love to hear your opinions on this!
It's hard to believe something as small as a peanut could cause so much controversy. But put it in a lunch bag and it can divide a school.
In Viola, Arkansas, a debate is heating up, after a student had his peanut butter and jelly sandwich confiscated at lunchtime. The school has a no-peanut-products policy due to a few students with allergies, so the teacher helped the little boy get a new lunch and sent home a note explaining the situation to his mom.
That note didn't go over well, apparently. Soon after the incident, a 'School Nut Ban Discussion' group was launched on Facebook by parents conflicted over the policy.
5 peanut myths debunked
Some parents believe allergy-free students shouldn't have to cater to a few kids' health sensitivities, particularly if it means cutting out healthy or low-cost snacks packed in their own child's lunchbox.
The mom who packed the confiscated PB&J sandwich thinks kids with allergies should learn "how to manage the problem" rather than live inside a "bubble," according to a local news report.
Other parents of special needs kids feel like they're playing second fiddle to those with allergies. "There are some autistic children that will only eat a PB&J sandwich or nothing at all," one parent opposing the ban argued on Facebook.
According to the Viola District Superintendent John
May, this is the first push-back on a policy in place in his school for some
time.
"The policy is in place to protect those with a
severe, life threatening problem," May told Area Wide News, a
Missouri-based news site. "Until we figure out something else, it would be
foolish to drop the policy."
Snack ideas for kids with nut allergies
Over the span of a decade, reports of kids with peanut allergies have spiked by 18 percent, according to the CDC. Today, about 1 in 25 children suffer from the condition, and about 18 percent of them have had attacks in school. As a result, school-wide peanut bans have doubled in the past two years. But they haven't come without a fight.
One Connecticut mother of an allergic child was
shocked by the hostility she was met with when proposing a peanut ban at her own
kid's school. "People were extremely rude," she told the Associated Press. "They
just thought it was a ridiculous request."
A child's well-being may have triggered the debate, but at the core of the conflict is a turf war. Is one parent's concerns about their own child interfering with the way other kids are raised? Some parents of allergic kids know being unpopular comes with the territory.
"Nobody wants to be a Peanut Allergy Mom," writes Mommyish blogger Gloria Fallon, whose son has severe life-threatening peanut allergies. "My main concern is my son's health, but I also don't want everyone to hate us. I actually am sorry for all the inconvenience having a PA kid creates. I know if my son didn't have food allergies, I'd probably think the kid who did was a pain in the a--. So I try to understand that for the most part, no one gets what we're going through."
Back in Viola, parents are looking for a compromise within the elementary school--hoping for a middle-ground approach some other institutions have taken. As opposed to banning nuts, some schools require all their teachers to be trained in using EpiPens, a life-saving device used in severe allergic attacks. Separating nut-eaters from non-nut-eaters in the lunchroom is another way to protect kids and raise awareness among students.
Major nut recall causes concerns
The Food Allergy & Anaphylaxis Network, a nut allergy advocacy group, believes compromise is better for kids with allergies than an outright ban. "What we want is everyone always thinking there could be a possibility (of an allergic reaction) and be on guard for it," the group's founder, Anne Munoz-Furlong, told the Associated Press.
But with compromise comes with new problems. Isolating a child at a separate table because of his or her allergies can create social ostracism and lead to bullying. (The American Pediatrics Association even cautions parents and teachers about the risk of harassment kids with peanut allergies face.)
Sitting at a special nut-free table or being the subject of a health lesson in class may save a kid's life but it won't win him any popularity contests. Fallon says that every time she drops her allergic son Nick off at a party, she has to run through worst case scenarios and procedures with the person in charge. "This usually results in the person looking frightened and probably wishing they didn't invite Nick," she says. "Nobody likes the finale, me especially."











5 comments:
This has always been such a difficult topic for me as my family grows peanuts! I grew up going to school with a girl who had a peanut allergy and we were all very aware of it and knew we had to be very careful around her. When we had parties, we couldn't bring any cookies or snacks with peanuts and that was just part of it.
Yes, it is so crazy that a small peanut can cause such much harm! I have friends who are allergic and he lives out in the country where lots of peanuts are grown. Sometimes he can walk outside and have an allergic reaction, just from the dust. In college, a girl on my hall had an allergy and when I brought boiled peanuts from home (a true southern staple snack), I had to warn her that she couldn't come in my room!
Is your daughter allergic to the dust or being in the same vacinity of peanuts or only if she physically touches them? IS she allergic to anything else? Poor thing, I know it must be hard. It just such an interesting debate!
I think a lot of these moms who put up a stick only do so because they want their kid to be the special one - that or lazy parenting. Sure, TC loves her some peanut butter but there are other options, you just have to think outside of the box.
If a child is sick with something life threatening the community rallies around them and does everything they can to help, but ask them to help save a life by leaving the peanuts at home and you may as well tell them that you are selling their first born. I am not saying that a child with an allergy is the same as a sick child I am just using this as a life and death example (so people do flood me with nasty comments).
I don't know if I am articulating what I really want to say - my coffee hasn't kicked in yet.
Here's my thoughts...
Preston doesn't have any allergies that we know of. But my brother is allergic to peanuts and has been since he was little. His is a milder allergy but still every. single. year. when he has to go in and get tested he tests positive. And my niece has been diagnosed with a cashew allergy. My brother is older now (19) so he knows to pack his epipen and check to see if when he takes a sip of your drink whether you've eaten anything with peanuts or to ask if something has peanuts in it or look himself. (Sidenote, his girlfriend, who we can't stand, has recently decided to mess around with this and TWICE has given him something that she KNOWS has peanuts in it and then told him "see you're fine." afterwards. Who the fuck does that?!) But my niece is only two. She's to little to understand her allergy yet. At all. Which means that it is the responsibility of the adults around her to watch out for her. And here's the thing, I love thai food love it. And my favorite dish is cashew chicken and since Brad hates thai food I only get to eat it when I visit my SIL. So now I order something different, the end. NO questions asked. The idea that if I ate it even after she'd gone to bed and then something happened to her and she had to be hospitalized or worse is so terrifying to me so I don't do anything that could allow that to happen. It's not even worth chancing.
While I get that these other parents might think it's irritating to have to avoid a food that they like to feed their child, let's be realistic here. It's ONE meal and it's only on school days. Deal with it. They can have their peanut butter when they get home. Where it isn't dangerous to another child. I don't even understand how you fight for the right to bring something around a child that can send them into an attack or end with them being hospitalized or worse. Selfish much? And the whole argument that it's not fair to their child? That's just crap. School is someplace that children HAVE to go. And they should be safe there. No questions asked.
Schools are also tobacco free environments. Are we supposed to feel bad for smokers because they can't smoke there? Even knowing that the smoke isn't healthy for small children? If someone attempted to make that argument people would be appalled! And I'm not really sure I see how the peanut argument in schools is any different. If a child is allergic to them and comes in contact with them, it's just as unhealthy as having a smoker sitting next to them at recess blowing it right in their face. And even that isn't as bad as a child with a nut allergy inhaling nuts!
It just seems like this lady is putting up a fight to put up a fight. It's not like the school is saying her kid can't eat peanut butter at all, just that he can't bring it to school. Really not that big of a deal.
AND let's say they change the rules and a child like Emmy did come in contact with it, have any of these parents thought about how scary it would be for their children to witness her having an attack? Or having to watch her epipen being used on her? Or having the teacher have to ignore every other child in the class room to help her and make her the only priority? Or having to call an ambulance and have her rushed to the hospital? And the possible guilt that the child who brought the peanut butter could feel? It just seems to me that when you look at all of the possible things that could happen it's really not a big deal to just say that nuts aren't allowed for the safety of ALL of the children.
I hope that made sense! Preston was climbing all over me while I was trying to put my thoughts on paper, errr keyboard! :)
My girls don't have allergies yet that we know of but I would do everything in my power to keep their peers at school healthy. In school, church or the community. My four year old doesn't like peanut butter no matter how much I beg her to. I can eat a jar a week. I never pack a pbj for me in a lunch box, always something else. I never know when I may or may not come into contact with someone who has an allergy. With my baby, I always wash my hands really well before even picking her up after having some. I would never want to be the reason someone had an attack, I'm okay with having my pbj at home. I also always ask when new friends come over. If an allergy, it goes in trash and I bleach/ scrub everything.
People are so insensitive! My kids don't have any food allergies, but I would 100% support a peanut ban if it ment helping another child. How sad some people don't see that. Especially moms. Scary world we live in.
Post a Comment